Johnny Newton Morehouse was born in 1855, the youngest son of John Newton Morehouse Sr. and his first wife, Mary Margaret (Browning) Morehouse. John and Mary were married December 23, 1851. Johnny’s older brother Horace Morehouse was born in 1852, also in Ohio.

John Newton Morehouse was born in 1828. He was a shoe cobbler until his death in 1903. In 1851 he married Mary, his first wife and mother to Horace and Johnny. They divorced and by the time Johnny died in 1860, John was married to his second wife, Barbara. After Barbara died in 1878, John lived a low-profile life as both a shoe cobbler and an active member of his church. He never remarried and remained in Dayton until his death in 1903.

Mary Margaret Browning remarried on October 25, 1870, to Nathaniel B. Young. Together, Nathaniel and Mary had two children, Jack Diamond Young (1870) and Nathaniel B. Young Jr. (1876). Eventually Mary, her husband, and the kids moved to Fort Wayne, Indiana. Nathaniel Sr. and his stepson Horace went into business together but had to declare bankruptcy in 1877. Mary and her family eventually moved to Washington where she lived until her death in 1927.

Horace moved to Fort Wayne, Indiana with his mother, stepfather, and half siblings and worked in the clothing business as a tailor. On January 8, 1889, he married the recently widowed Alice Wood (Van Phul) after a brief and secret courtship, which caused a major scandal and led to the Cincinnati Sun writing a smear article about it. (Read about it here).

By the end of February 1889, Alice alleged that Horace had abandoned her and filed for divorce. After three years of “abandonment” Alice was granted her divorce. Years later, Horace married Kitty Gilbert and shortly after, they had a son. A few years later, Horace moved his family to Seattle, where he became advertising manager for the Seattle Post Intelligencer. Horace died in 1898 after a 5-week illness.