Quick Dayton Stories

Sometimes while doing research for other stories (or for books), we come across interesting stories that aren’t long enough for a blog post but are still interesting! Here are a few:

    • December 1946 – Police rushed to the scene after a woman reporting a freshly dug grave near her home. The grave was adorned with a large floral display. Deputy Sheriff Ben Brown dug for several minutes before finding a large box tied with a fancy ribbon. The scene was silent as the Deputy Sheriff lifted the box from the ground and untied the ribbon to see a large silk handkerchief inside. In it, he found a dead canary.
    • March 1802 (reported December 1802) – While Jonathan Dayton attended a session of Congress in Washington DC, he had an experience of “Spontaneous Combustion”. While undressing himself at bedtime, Dayton removed a pair of silk stockings he wore over a pair of woolen stockings. He dropped the silk stockings onto a woolen carpet near the side of the bed. One of his garters fell down with the silk stockings. The white woolen stockings were tossed farther away, near the foot of the bed. Dayton noticed a bit of sparking when he separated the silk stockings from the wool ones, which he gave no mind, since he had seen that before. He slept through the night as normal. In the morning a servant entered in the morning to kindle the fire, waking Dayton. Dayton then noticed his silk stockings were a brown color and one of his leather slippers was burnt. The garter that fell next to the silk stocking was charred but intact. Upon closer examination, the leather slipper and the garter only were burnt in the parts that had been in contact with the silk stockings. Both Dayton and the servant attending him noted there were no candles burning in the room and the fireplace was at least 9 feet away and burning low. Based on the evidence, they concluded it was spontaneous combustion.
    • September 1997 – A plain pine box with the skeletal remains of at least two early Daytonians, buried in St Henry Cemetery in the late 1800s, was laid to rest during a service and burial at Calvary Cemetery. Workers found the bones while laying a sewer line for the Miami Valley Hospital’s new Emergency and Surgery Complex. Cemetery Superintendent Rick Meade provided green carpeting and a red tent, hospital carpenters made the pine box, and Miami Valley sent a pot of mums for the service. The land had been the site of St Henry’s Catholic Cemetery. The city of Dayton had grown around St Henry’s, leaving it with no room to expand. The cemetery hit hard times, unable to keep up with maintenance. That’s when the trustees decided to sell the cemetery and move the bodies to Calvary. Roughly 6,000 bodies were moved from St Henry to Calvary, and 4,013 were unclaimed. The unclaimed were buried in a mass grave at Calvary Cemetery where the Memorial Chapel stands. The chapel was built from funds derived from the sale of St Henry and dedicated to the unclaimed souls. The Memorial Chapel was dedicated on All Souls Day, November 2, 1902. In the service provided for the reinterred, Rev. Richard Knuge, chaplain at Miami Valley Hospital, read “We commend these remains to the Lord, that the Lord may embrace them in peace and raise up their bodies on the last day”, from the Roman Ritual, Order of Christian Funerals. “We are dust and into dust we shall return. Blessed is the Lord.”

The Grave at UD

Between Marycrest Dorm and the Health Center at UD lies a small cemetery (Marianist Cemetery), which was supposed to be for the Marianist brothers who lived and worked at the University. The markers are small and flush on the ground but for one, a grave dedicated to a four month old child who died in 1848. The gravestone for Mary Louisa Stuart is an elaborate monument that seems to be out of place among the burials of celibates. So how did this grave come to be there? To answer this question, let’s look at some history.

The Founder of the Society of Mary, Father Leo Meyer, came from Alsace to Cincinnati to serve as a missionary in 1949. He found the area in the midst of a cholera epidemic and volunteered to help. The next year he was sent by the Bishop to Dayton to serve at Emmanuel Church, where he met John Stuart.

Stuart owned 125 acres of farmland in the Southeastern section of Dayton. Stuart had come from Scotland and wanted to return, and Father Meyer wanted to establish a colony of Marianists. The two negotiated and made a deal. Stuart would give the land to Father Meyer and allow him to pay back when he could, and Father Meyer would give him his St Joseph Medal as collateral. It took twenty years to pay the debt and get back the medal.

Mary Stuart, infant daughter of John, was buried in St Henry Catholic Cemetery, on Main Street near Ashley and Frank Streets. When St Henry was sold and the bodies exhumed, Father Meyer moved Mary and her monument to the UD Campus in order to fulfill his promise to John Stuart that he would always care for the child’s grave. When the Marianist cemetery was established in the present location, Mary’s grave was moved along with the rest. Stewart Street is named for the Stuart family, but the name was misspelled.

K12 Gallery and Tejas

The K12 Gallery and Teen Educational and Joint Adult Studio (TEJAS) located at 341 S Jefferson Street is a visual arts center inspiring people of all ages to create art in an encouraging environment. There are over 400 on-site art classes and exhibitions and over 1000 off site classes at 15 urban locations. The center was created in 1993 by teacher Jerri Stanard. Through her dedication to engaging people through arts, she has turned the non-profit into the leader for visual arts in the Dayton area.

One avenue of community engagement is introducing the healing power of arts to low-income students, youth on probation, adults with disabilities, and survivors of domestic violence. K12 Gallery & TEJAS continues to organize public art projects to further reach the community.

For information on art classes at K12 & TEJAS, please visit their website at: https://k12tejasgallery.org

Holiday Hiatus 2024

As Dayton Unknown does every year for the holidays, we are going to take a break for the rest of the year to enjoy time with our families. We are always accessible through the Contact Us page, Dayton Unknown on Facebook, and by email – daytonunknown@hotmail.com. Don’t forget to check out our Instagram as well, at @daytonunknown!! We’ll see you all in 2025!

Coming Soon: Murder in Victorian Dayton, the Tragic Story of Bessie Little

Sara’s next book will have a publication date! Murder in Victorian Dayton, the Tragic Story of Bessie Little will be available March 4, 2025. You can order directly from Sara’s Website, Amazon, or buy on March 29 2025 at the Paranormal Gathering at The Windamere in Middletown. Sara will be selling her books and speaking at the event.

Local Author Tim Smith

Dayton resident Tim Smith is an award-winning and bestselling author of books ranging from romantic mystery/thriller to contemporary light romance. Tim has been a published author for over 20 years and he has just released his 30th book. He is also a freelance writer, photographer, and editor. When he isn’t pursuing one of his careers, he can be found in the Florida Keys, parasailing and seeking out the perfect Piña Colada.
Some of Tim Smith’s titles include:

  • One Lonely Christmas Eve
  • Memories Die Last
  • Cupid Says Happy New Year
  • Who Gets the Friends
  • The Sweet Distraction

You can buy his books on Amazon.

Natalie Babbit

Natalie Babbitt (née Moore) was an American writer and illustrator of children’s books. She wrote Tuck Everlasting, which was adapted into two films and a musical on Broadway.

Natalie was born in Dayton on July 28, 1932, to personnel administrator Ralph Moore and former artist Genevieve Converse Moore. Natalie grew up with what she referred to as an “Ohio life view”, which she described as “the feeling that certain things are right, and that’s that.

Since childhood, Natalie wanted to be an illustrator. She studied at Laurel School in Cleveland and Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts. Later, she married Samuel Babbitt, and together they had three children, born between 1956 and 1960.

Together, the couple created The Forty-ninth Magician, written by Samuel and illustrated by Natalie. Eventually Samuel became too busy to continue with books and Natalie was encouraged to continue producing children’s books. She started with short books, then continued on to children’s novels.

Children’s novels was where Natalie succeeded. For her books, she won the following awards:

  • Tuck Everlasting – named an ALA Notable Book and ranked among the “Top 100 Chapter Books” of all time by the School Library Journal. Adapted into a movie twice and a Broadway Musical
  • The Eyes of Amaryllis – adapted into a movie in 1982.
  • Received The Newbery Honor Award
  • Received the Christopher Award
  • U.S. Nominee for Hans Christian Andersen Award in 1982
  • Finalist for Edgar Allan Poe Award
  • Awarded the inaugural E.B. White Award for achievement in children’s literature by the American Academy of Arts and Letters.

Natalie’s writing career spanned four decades and produced 20 books she wrote and 10 she illustrated. She also illustrated five volumes in the Small Poems Series by Valerie Worth. She was a frequent contributor to The Times Book Review, continuing to write into her 70s.

Natalie died on October 31, 2016 at her home in Hamden Connecticut. She had lung cancer. She was survived by her husband Samuel, and her three children, Dr Christopher Converse Babbitt, Thomas Collier Babbitt, and Lucy Cullyford Babbitt.

Regarding the subject of immortality from Tuck Everlasting, Natalie echoed Angus Tuck. “I think that living forever would be a terrible thing,” she once said. “ It would be boring, sad and lonely.”